Loss of Control Increases Belief in Precognition and Belief in Precognition Increases Control

Abstract

Katharine H. Greenaway*, Winnifred R. Louis, Matthew J. Hornsey
The University of Queensland, School of Psychology, Brisbane, Queensland, Australia

Every year thousands of dollars are spent on psychics who claim to “know” the future. The present research questions why, despite no evidence that humans are able to psychically predict the future, do people persist in holding irrational beliefs about precognition? We argue that believing the future is predictable increases one’s own perceived ability to exert control over future events. As a result, belief in precognition should be particularly strong when people most desire control–that is, when they lack it. In Experiment 1 (N = 87), people who were experimentally induced to feel low in control reported greater belief in precognition than people who felt high in control. Experiment 2 (N = 53) investigated whether belief in precognition increases perceived control. Consistent with this notion, providing scientific evidence that precognition is possible increased feelings of control relative to providing scientific evidence that precognition was not possible. Experiment 3 (N = 132) revealed that when control is low, believing in precognition helps people to feel in control once more. Prediction therefore acts as a compensatory mechanism in times of low control. The present research provides new insights into the psychological functions of seemingly irrational beliefs, like belief in psychic abilities.

Download Full Paper

Advertisements

The relationship between susceptibility to false memories, dissociativity, and paranormal belief and experience.

Krissy Wilson and Christopher C. French
Anomalistic Psychology Research Unit,
Department of Psychology,
Goldsmiths College,
University of London,
New Cross,
London SE14 6NW.

Abstract
One hundred participants completed a News Coverage Questionnaire concerning personal memories of where they were, what they were doing and who they were with when news footage of dramatic news events was first shown on television, as well as asking them to recall details of the footage itself. These news items included four events that are known to have been captured on film and one item concerning nonexistent footage of the bombing of a nightclub in Bali. Overall, 36% of respondents reported false memories of the alleged footage of the Bali bombing. Participants reporting false memories were found to score significantly higher than those who did not report such memories on the Australian Sheep-Goat Scale, on various sub-scales of the Anomalous Experiences Inventory (Belief, Experience and Ability) and on the Dissociative Experiences Scale, supporting the hypothesis that believers in the paranormal may be more susceptible to false memories than non-believers.

Keywords : False memories; dissociation; paranormal belief and experience.

Download Full Paper

Critical thinking ability and belief in the paranormal

Andreas Hergovich a,*, Martin Arendasy a
a Institute of Psychology of the University of Vienna, Liebigg. 5, 1010 Vienna, Austria
Received 10 March 2004;received in revised form 30 September 2004;accepted 1 November 2004
Available online 2 February 2005

Abstract
A study was conducted to assess the relationship between critical thinking and belief in the paranormal. 180 students from three departments (psychology, arts, computer science) completed one measure of reasoning, the Paranormal Belief Scale (Tobacyk & Milford, 1983), and a scale of paranormal experiences. Half of the subjects filled out the Cornell Critical Thinking Test (Ennis & Millmann, 1985) and the Watson–Glaser Critical Thinking Appraisal (Watson & Glaser, 2002), respectively. The results show no significant correlations between critical thinking and paranormal belief or experiences. Reasoning ability, however, had a significant effect on paranormal belief scores, but not on paranormal experiences. Subjects with lower reasoning ability scored higher on Traditional Paranormal Belief and New Age Philosophy than did subjects with higher reasoning abilities. Results suggest that those who have better reasoning abilities scrutinise to a greater extent whether their experiences are sufficient justification for belief in the reality of these phenomena.
2004 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
Keywords: Critical thinking ability;Paranormal belief;Paranormal experiences;Reasoning ability

Download Full Paper

The Amazing Work of Dr. Persinger – What’s in your environment?

The God Helmet 

When I first began my research into unusual things I had (like many) a pretty strong belief in the possibility of some form of after-life existence. The idea of a wandering human soul didn’t really seem like a stretch to me and I admit I was a sucker for the all of the popular hype. It’s a tough thing to admit, but I was open to and fascinated by the idea of Ouija Boards, Tarot Cards, pendulums, Psychics and yes, I even got excited about orb photos (Yikes! Did I just say that?). Anyone who knows me today might find it all hard to believe considering my often vocal penchant for critical thinking and scientific methods.  Well that was 11 years ago and like any good student of life I developed with research. Education and study are the true monster killers of this world and their strength is certainly formidable.

With all that being said, let me add that in spite of my new-found rationalization, my belief and interest in unusual things has certainly not disappeared. In fact I still believe there are unusual and elusive things left to discover in this world. Some of them down-right freaky. But the difference now is that I approach this work, this vocation, this hobby, this passion (what ever you want to call it) with two feet firmly planted on the ground and a large supply of salt to cushion my skeptical ears.

Part of my research in recent years has involved the subject of human perception. Clearly, as humans, our perceptions and faculties (not to mention our limbic system) are the ambassadors to our experiences and our grasp on reality is only as good as they are correct. I know there are hundreds of behavioral processes in your mind right now that will argue to the contrary, but trust me, we are not in good shape.  I do believe most (97% or more) of the worlds “paranormal” experiences can be attributed to failures or inefficiencies in the way we think, react and perceive. Some of these perception failures are built-in and it’s simply a process of our behavior or neural function. But others come from the outside.

Anyone with even a rudimentary interest in Paranormal Research will have at some point, heard of EMF (Electro-magnetic fields). “Ghost Hunters” of all types run through purported active locations looking for readings from a field of energy on a meter that most investigators don’t truly understand (I’ll talk more about that in another article). Not many people realize that the search for “EMF” was a search for natural causes, not for energy disturbed by dis-incarnate beings. That’s right, all of those things you read about Ghosts giving off EMF or disturbing EMF or being made of EMF were actually unsubstantiated “guesses” made by people who failed to research the reasoning behind the measurements.

The fact is the lion share of the EMF hype all started in Canada with a neuropsychologist named Dr. MIchael Persinger. His work in identifying an apparent connection between electromagnetic stimulation of the brain and perceived paranormal experiences started college researchers searching “active” homes for EMF sources that might trigger the unusual effect. It was really a method of debunking. Yet today a hit on an EMF meter or KII is often considered a “sign” of a ghost. Truly its testimony to one more human failure… the failure to properly research a concept before teaching it to others.

In closing I leave you with an excellent report from one of the researchers at Laurentian college, exploring some of Dr. Persinger’s amazing work… Enjoy.

Oh and by the way, in the physics world “EMF” actually stands for “Electro-Motive Force” not Eletro-Magnetic Fields. The “EMF” Monicker was coined by folks uneducated to the true science nomenclature. “EMF” Meters are actually “Electro-Magnetometers”  – The more you know..

The neuromagnetics research of neuropsychologist Dr. Michael Persinger is given a cursory review in regard to Temporal Lobe Transients (TLTs) which are implicated as mini-seizures in producing a variety of perceptual anomalies combined with a sense of deep meaning. Persinger identifies the temporal lobes as the biological basis of the God Experience, “the God Module,” in his 1987 book Neuropsychological Bases of God Beliefs.

He comments on the purpose of his research: “As a human being, I am concerned about the illusionary explanations for human consciousness and the future of human existence.  Consequently after writing [NBGB], I began the systematic application of complex electromagnetic fields to discern the patterns that will induce experiences (sensed presence) that are attributed to the myriad of ego-alien intrusions which range from gods to aliens.  The research is not to demean anyone’s religious/mystical experience but instead to determine which portions of the brain or its electromagnetic patterns generate the experience.  Two thousand years of philosophy have taught us that attempting to prove or disprove realities may never have discrete verbal (linguistic) solutions because of the limitation of this measurement.  The research has been encouraged by the historical fact that most wars and group degradations are coupled implicitly to god beliefs and to the presumption that those who do not believe the same as the experient are somehow less human and hence expendable.  Although these egocentric propensities may have had adaptive significance, their utility for the species’ future may be questionable.”

His technique, using solenoids in a helmet for input, is fairly simple.  A hand-held computer programs the predefined pattern at which the fields will fluctuate. The impulses move through the temporal lobe and penetrate deep into the brain, where they interfere and interact with the complex electrical patterns of the subject’s neural fields. The new patterns spread through the limbic system, producing sensations that range from subtle to profound. 

Persinger’s research goal is to use his device to trigger transcendental experiences in nonreligious people faced with the fear of death. Persinger has tickled the temporal lobes of around a 1000 people and has concluded, among other things, that different subjects label this ghostly perception with the names that their cultures have trained them to use — Elijah, Jesus, the Virgin Mary, Mohammed, the Sky Spirit.  Some subjects have emerged with Freudian interpretations – describing the presence as one’s grandfather, for instance – while others, agnostics with more than a passing faith in UFOs, tell something that sounds more like a standard alien-abduction story.

Persinger has discovered that when he aims for the amygdala, his subjects experience sexual arousal. When he focuses the solenoids on the right hemisphere of their temporal lobes, they sense on the left side of their body a negative presence — an alien or a devil, say. When he switches to left left hemisphere, his subjects sense a benevolent force: an angel or a god. Focused on the hippocampus, the personal electromagnetic relaxation device will produce the sort of opiate effects that Ecstasy does today. So far, subjects report no adverse side effects. However, “if you interfere with the opiate pattern, people get very irritated,” Persinger says. In fact, “they’ll actually cuss you out.”

Persinger asserts that, “God Experiences are products of the human brain.  When certain portions of the brain are stimulated, God Experiences, tempered by the person’s learning history, are evoked.  They appear to have emerged within the human species as a means of dealing with the expanded capacity to anticipate aversive events.  God Experiences contain common themes of “knowing,” forced thinking, inner voices, familiarity, and sensations of uplifting movements.”  God Concepts are determined by verbal conditioning; perceptions are constructions.  When multiple events occur within a week, they are usually given special labels, such as “revelations,” “communions,” or “conversions.”

People with TLTs experience vivid landscapes or perceive forms of living things.  Some of these entities are not humans, but are described as little men, glowing forms, or bright, shining sources.  The modality of the experience, that is, whether it is experienced as a sound, a smell, a scene (vision), or an intense feeling, reflects the area of the electrical instability.  The experiences, whether visual or auditory, may have actually happened or they may be mixtures of fantasy and reality.  Sometimes they may be fixed in space and time, while in other cases they may be as dynamic as everyday experiences.  However, whether they are dreamlike or vivid, they are experienced as real.

Persinger is not saying that the experiences of God are synonymous with temporal lobe epilepsy.  However,  when vast depolarizing waves spread across millions of cells, all types of memories and fantasies are mixed and mashed together.  But the God Experience is a normal and more organized pattern of temporal lobe activity, precipitated by subtle psychological factors such as personal stress, loss, and anticipated death. The gut feeling is a sense of familiarity, deep meaning, conviction and importance, even euphoria or mania (alternately fear and terror).  The brain’s chemical reaction is to release natural opiates and other mood elevating neurotransmitters. 

During TLTs, the person peers into another realm which has many names, heaven, the world of spirits, or the other dimension.  Trained meditators, (employing rhythmic stimulus to the CNS such as a mantra or “emptying”, changes in oxygen and blood sugar levels), can drive the temporal lobe into bouts of theta activity.  Sometimes frank electrical seizures occur and the God Experience is reported.

Neuroscientist Todd Murphy, http://www.jps.net/brainsci/, has done a good job of summarizing Persinger’s research in simpler language.  He describes consciousness as a feedback interface of sensory and cognitive modalities.  Low intensity magnetic fields orchestrate communication between lobes of the brain, at a speed much faster than the bioelectrical or biochemical process of neurons.  Different signals produce different phenomena.   

The temporal lobes are the parts of the brain that mediate states of consciousness. Multiple modalities are experienced simultaneously, with the implication that they are ‘reset’ all at once by neuromagnetic signals which come in pairs, running slightly out of phase with one another.  In this way, neuromagnetic signals, like the two laser beams used to produce a hologram, might be able to store information.  The speeds at which neuromagnetic signals are propagated and their capacity to recruit/alter multiple modalities suggests that they were naturally selected to make instant choices to alter states of consciousness, and to do so quickly to facilitate adaptive behavior.

Murphy’s many articles include not only the production of consciousness and states of consciousness, the God experience, but deja vu, and the spiritual personality.  Long-term memory is seated in the surface of the bottom of the temporal lobes in the para hippocampal cortex, closely connected to the hippocampus.  Usually, there is seamless integration of past, present and future.  We experience something in the present, compare it to the past and decide how to respond in a few seconds.

But once in a while, in Deja Vu, there is too much communication between short-term and long-term memories.  Then the present can feel like the past.  If present perceptions are shunted through the brain areas that process memories from the past, those perceptions feel like memories, and we feel we are re-living a moment stored in long-term memory. The opposite happens in Jamais Vu:  things seem totally unfamiliar because of too little connection between long-term memory and perceptions from the present.  

Nothing we experience seems to have anything to do with the past.  If these experiences spill over into the amygdala they are highly emotional.  If goes to the right it is unpleasant or fearful, to the left from ecstatic to beatific.  Another experiential phenomenon is time distortion. Murphy describes the phenomenon of the Sensed Presence and how it emerges from out of phase processes in different hemispheres of the brain. 

He also relates the sensed presence with the behavior and feelings of romantic love. The ‘self’ is what we experience when a specific pattern of brain activity is happening.  It is linked to the Forty Hertz Component which appears from the temporal lobes, and two of it’s deeper structures, the amygdala and the hippocampus.  The 40 Hz signal is only not there in dreamless sleep. 

The maintenance of the sense of self is repeated 40 times per second and each time it can manifest a new emotional response to changing circumstances every 25 milliseconds. These structures on both sides of the brain yield two ‘selves,’ two senses of self.  One is on the left, and one on the right, but they are not equals.  The left-sided sense of self is dominant in most people; right side subordinate non-verbal, introspective.  The left is the one where language happens, maintaining our stream of inner words and thoughts about everything we experience or can imagine.

Each normal brain function involves a primary operative area on one side with a subordinate homologous or corresponding area on the other.  On the other side of the brain, following the rule that each thing on one side of the brain does the opposite of what the same thing on the other side does, we get the conclusion that there is a non-linguistic sense of self on the right side of the brain.  Usually the two selves work in tandem.  But if the two fall out of phase, and the left-sided self manifests by itself, we experience our own, right-sided silent sense of self coming out where the left sided sense of self experiences it as “other,” as not-self.  This leads to the phenomenon of Sensed Presence, actually the Silent Self.

amygdala112

Electrical activity in the amygdala, hippocampus and temporal can ‘spill over’ into nearby structures.  If it ignites the visual area, intense visions of an entity of some sort emerge (left amygdala-positive imagery; right side-negative images/entities).  Kindling the olfactory region leads to unique scents; the somatosensory stimulation leads to buzzing, energetic, or tingly sensations or perceptions of being lifted or floating; language center activation produces voices, music or noise; long-term memory (lower portion of temporal lobes) access yields interactive virtual realities, complete with emotions, much like waking dreams. 

The thalamus is implicated in aura vision, and the reticular activating system in life reviews. Because positive thoughts (involving the right hippocampus), and positive feelings (involving the left amygdala) are on opposite sides of the brain, prayer or meditation changes the balance of activity on the two sides.  These structures have some of the lowest firing thresholds in the brain and are thus likely to mismatch their metabolic rates of activity. 

Whenever that’s happening, chances of the activity of the two sides falling out of phase with each other increases. Then the ‘right self’ is experienced as an external presence. Sensed presence experiences become more common until the day arrives when God’s presence is something the person feels at all times. 

In mystical experience language fails, and a person’s sense of themselves can be transformed.  Since we can’t experience two senses of self, one is projected as other, the Beloved, either romantic or spiritual.  There is thus some truth to the saying that the beloved is God, and that when we love God we are loving ourselves.  I and Thou are One.  The other becomes the Self.

References:

Greater electroencephalographic coherence between left and right temporal lobe structures during increased geomagnetic activity
KS Saroka, A Lapointe, MA Persinger
Neuroscience letters 560, 126-1307
2014

https://neurocogconsultants.app.box.com/s/l9f7tld3yjny4b00eqbq

The New & Improved Paraphysics – 1996

Research Item – http://qpsychics.com/

The etymology of the word Paraphysics is quite interesting as is the history of paraphysics itself. The word seems to have been coined in the late nineteenth century by the German psychiatrist and psychical researcher Baron Albert F. von Schrenck-Notzing, (Beal in Mitchell, p.486) so it dates from the same era as the word parapsychology. But its modern usage is not nearly as wide as the word parapsychology. For example, parapsychology is well defined and can be found in any standard dictionary or encyclopedia. The history of the word parapsychology can be found in many general books on the subject or encyclopedias dedicated to parapsychology and/or the paranormal as well as standard dictionaries and encyclopedias. The popularity of the term parapsychology and its general acceptance as the name of a field of science, although that acceptance has been given begrudgingly by some scientists and other scholars, no doubt stems from the seminal work done by Joseph B. Rhine in the 1930’s and thereafter. Many other scientists have followed the path paved by Rhine and added tremendously to the field.

Download Full Study

Turkish Poltergeist – 1995

On Monday 15th May, 1995, the Parapsychology Institute in Utrecht received a request for help from a Turkish family in the village of Druten in Holland. The phenomena this family experienced were recognized as classical poltergeist events: the flying about of stones, clods of earth, sand, and objects, some of them hitting people and smashing windows. Family members were frightened by these events which seemed to concentrate around Çetin, the 15 year old son. Apart from Çetin, the family consists of his father Rafet (48 yrs), step-mother Saime (55 yrs), and half-sister Aynur (16 yrs). Other main characters in the event were Gülseren, the older half-sister of Çetin (25 yrs) who lives nearby, Dorus, a friend of Rafet, and neighbours Wies and Simon.

Download Full Report

A Proposal and Challenge for Proponents and Skeptics of PSI – 2004

Research Item – J.E. Kennedy
(Original publication and copyright: Journal of Parapsychology, 2004,
Volume 68, pages 157-167.)

ABSTRACT: Pharmaceutical research provides a useful model for doing convincing research in situations with intense, critical scrutiny of studies. The protocol for a “pivotal” study that is used for decision-making is reviewed by the FDA before the study is begun. The protocol is expected to include a power analysis demonstrating that the study has at least a .8 probability of obtaining significant results with the anticipated effect size, and to specify the statistical analysis that will determine the success of the experiment, including correction for multiple analyses. FDA inspectors often perform audits of the sites where data are collected and/or processed to verify the raw data and experimental procedures. If parapsychological experiments are to provide convincing evidence, power analyses should be done at the planning stage. A committee of experienced parapsychologists, moderate skeptics, and a statistician could review and comment on protocols for proposed “pivotal” studies in an effort to address methodological issues before rather than after the data are collected. The evidence that increasing sample size does not increase the probability of significant results in psi research may prevent the application of these methods and raises questions about the experimental approach for psi research.

 

Download Full Study