The survival of consciousness: Junk science or visionary inspiration

Anyone who dabbles or dives into the research of paranormal phenomena understands the impact that finding hard evidence of life after death can have, not only to the paranormal community, but to life on this planet in general.  For better or worse it would have a profound effect on our concept of existence.  It may alter or support some theological perspectives and even ding the hard shell of a few Atheists. However, much to the detriment of the after-life supporters there have been zero discoveries that have put us any closer to a conclusive answer on the elusive subject.

Purveyors of this fascinating concept often quote (but rarely understand) the fundamental principles maintained by the law of conservation of energy. The most popular quote is “Energy can neither be created, nor destroyed, but transforms from one form to another.” Ironically, one consequence of this “law” is that no system without an external energy supply can deliver an unlimited amount of energy to its surroundings. A paradox that some believe fails to support the very claim this “law quote” is used to endorse.  We can not exist without a source of energy. From the point of conception our biological structure is “jump started” into life from our direct connection to another living being (our mother). When our bodies maintain a stable foundation and can supply the needed energy on their own we are separated (born) and continue to live until the energy source (our bodies) deteriorates and ultimately dies, thus ending the life process.

Spiritualists maintain that our life begins with the creation of a “vehicle” (our body) to house a separate consciousness that existed before our conception and will exist after we die. Of course this goes against the fundamental principles of the conservation of energy law, since the “soul” would have no direct energy source prior to conception or following death. If it did, what would be the purpose of introducing a second, age limited energy supply (our bodies) capable of deterioration? To me, there are significant holes in this logic.

Recently I came across an article (shown below) entitled: “Scientists Claim That Quantum Theory Proves Consciousness Moves To Another Universe At Death.”  It was an intriguing title for sure, although it contained a significant error. You see a “Theory” will never “Prove” a concept since a theory is unproven itself. Regardless I thought it might be an interesting read.

The article speaks about the work of scientist Dr. Robert Lanza and quotes the “beliefs” of many scientists (key word there) including that of Dr. Stuart Hameroff and British physicist Sir Roger Penrose.  Since I do not accept someone credibility purely based upon their title, I decided to conduct some research of my own. One of the interesting things I found was a book written in 2002 by Dr. Penrose called “The Emperors New Mind”.  The premise of the book is that human consciousness is not simply a product of complex algorithms but rather a process that can not be measured by the current scientific model. Many of the arguments he makes in support of his claims are purely philosophical in nature and unfortunately most of his conclusions are based on his own observations (hardly conclusive science), Those observations are then used to reason out larger principles.

His references to actual scientific experimentation are scarce. An online review of his work seemed to say it best:

Even when he does make an appeal to actual experimentation, he often comes to bizarre conclusions. For example, an experiment wherein an electrode is placed into a person’s brain which causes them to not be aware that their skin was touched when the electrode is activated within a quarter of a second after someone touched them leads Penrose to conclude that the effect of the electrode is traveling backwards in time.” – Bizarre and unfounded.

The lack of scientific methodology is indeed disheartening since Penrose is a tremendously respected, award winning scientist in the world of physics. Unfortunately those accolades do not by default make his “opinions” correct, especially in a field of research that has little solid surface to stand on.

My investigation into the work of the other scientists quoted in this article produced similar results (in-fact several of them work together). It seems the position of all these brilliant men is to refute the claims of those researchers in artificial intelligence and cognitive neuroscience who claim that the mind is a product of algorithmic processes. They feel that human consciousness is far more diverse than a set of mathematical calculations. Which is fine of course, but as seen in this article, the problem remains that they simply skipped all the fantastic reality there is to modern physics, and substituted speculation to arrive at an end result that is in support of their belief…. not good science.

In my opinion, articles such as this one are dangerous. To those who simply read and fail to research, the large amount of PhD’s referenced in this text presents a facade of credibility. Let me state very clearly for everyone’s benefit: An acclaimed group of physicists “belief” in an unproven and un-testable concept does not increase the concepts plausibility. Do your own research. Question everything.

Note: Beware of blogs making scientific claims that only site Wikipedia and other blogs as their source of information.


Here is the article I promised:

Scientists Claim That Quantum Theory Proves Consciousness Moves To Another Universe At Death

A book titled “Biocentrism: How Life and Consciousness Are the Keys to Understanding the Nature of the Universe“ has stirred up the Internet, because it contained a notion that life does not end when the body dies, and it can last forever. The author of this publication, scientist Dr. Robert Lanza who was voted the 3rd most important scientist alive by the NY Times, has no doubts that this is possible.

Beyond time and space

Lanza is an expert in regenerative medicine and scientific director of Advanced Cell Technology Company. Before he has been known for his extensive research which dealt with stem cells, he was also famous for several successful experiments on cloning endangered animal species.

But not so long ago, the scientist became involved with physics, quantum mechanics and astrophysics. This explosive mixture has given birth to the new theory of biocentrism, which the professor has been preaching ever since.  Biocentrism teaches that life and consciousness are fundamental to the universe.  It is consciousness that creates the material universe, not the other way around.

Lanza points to the structure of the universe itself, and that the laws, forces, and constants of the universe appear to be fine-tuned for life, implying intelligence existed prior to matter.  He also claims that space and time are not objects or things, but rather tools of our animal understanding.  Lanza says that we carry space and time around with us “like turtles with shells.” meaning that when the shell comes off (space and time), we still exist.

The theory implies that death of consciousness simply does not exist.   It only exists as a thought because people identify themselves with their body. They believe that the body is going to perish, sooner or later, thinking their consciousness will disappear too.  If the body generates consciousness, then consciousness dies when the body dies.  But if the body receives consciousness in the same way that a cable box receives satellite signals, then of course consciousness does not end at the death of the physical vehicle. In fact, consciousness exists outside of constraints of time and space. It is able to be anywhere: in the human body and outside of it. In other words, it is non-local in the same sense that quantum objects are non-local.

Lanza also believes that multiple universes can exist simultaneously.  In one universe, the body can be dead. And in another it continues to exist, absorbing consciousness which migrated into this universe.  This means that a dead person while traveling through the same tunnel ends up not in hell or in heaven, but in a similar world he or she once inhabited, but this time alive. And so on, infinitely.  It’s almost like a cosmic Russian doll afterlife effect.

Multiple worlds

This hope-instilling, but extremely controversial theory by Lanza has many unwitting supporters, not just mere mortals who want to live forever, but also some well-known scientists. These are the physicists and astrophysicists who tend to agree with existence of parallel worlds and who suggest the possibility of multiple universes. Multiverse (multi-universe) is a so-called scientific concept, which they defend. They believe that no physical laws exist which would prohibit the existence of parallel worlds.

The first one was a science fiction writer H.G. Wells who proclaimed in 1895 in his story “The Door in the Wall”.  And after 62 years, this idea was developed by Dr. Hugh Everett in his graduate thesis at the Princeton University. It basically posits that at any given moment the universe divides into countless similar instances. And the next moment, these “newborn” universes split in a similar fashion. In some of these worlds you may be present: reading this article in one universe, or watching TV in another.

The triggering factor for these multiplyingworlds is our actions, explained Everett. If we make some choices, instantly one universe splits into two with different versions of outcomes.

In the 1980s, Andrei Linde, scientist from the Lebedev’s Institute of physics, developed the theory of multiple universes. He is now a professor at Stanford University.  Linde explained: Space consists of many inflating spheres, which give rise to similar spheres, and those, in turn, produce spheres in even greater numbers, and so on to infinity. In the universe, they are spaced apart. They are not aware of each other’s existence. But they represent parts of the same physical universe.

The fact that our universe is not alone is supported by data received from the Planck space telescope. Using the data, scientists have created the most accurate map of the microwave background, the so-called cosmic relic background radiation, which has remained since the inception of our universe. They also found that the universe has a lot of dark recesses represented by some holes and extensive gaps.

Theoretical physicist Laura Mersini-Houghton from the North Carolina University with her colleagues argue: the anomalies of the microwave background exist due to the fact that our universe is influenced by other universes existing nearby. And holes and gaps are a direct result of attacks on us by neighboring universes.

Soul

So, there is abundance of places or other universes where our soul could migrate after death, according to the theory of neo-biocentrism. But does the soul exist?  Is there any scientific theory of consciousness that could accommodate such a claim?  According to Dr. Stuart Hameroff, a near-death experience happens when the quantum information that inhabits the nervous system leaves the body and dissipates into the universe.  Contrary to materialistic accounts of consciousness, Dr. Hameroff offers an alternative explanation of consciousness that can perhaps appeal to both the rational scientific mind and personal intuitions.

Consciousness resides, according to Stuart and British physicist Sir Roger Penrose, in the microtubules of the brain cells, which are the primary sites of quantum processing.  Upon death, this information is released from your body, meaning that your consciousness goes with it. They have argued that our experience of consciousness is the result of quantum gravity effects in these microtubules, a theory which they dubbed orchestrated objective reduction (Orch-OR).

Consciousness, or at least proto-consciousness is theorized by them to be a fundamental property of the universe, present even at the first moment of the universe during the Big Bang. “In one such scheme proto-conscious experience is a basic property of physical reality accessible to a quantum process associated with brain activity.”

Our souls are in fact constructed from the very fabric of the universe – and may have existed since the beginning of time.  Our brains are just receivers and amplifiers for the proto-consciousness that is intrinsic to the fabric of space-time. So is there really a part of your consciousness that is non-material and will live on after the death of your physical body?

Dr Hameroff told the Science Channel’s Through the Wormhole documentary: “Let’s say the heart stops beating, the blood stops flowing, the microtubules lose their quantum state. The quantum information within the microtubules is not destroyed, it can’t be destroyed, it just distributes and dissipates to the universe at large”.  Robert Lanza would add here that not only does it exist in the universe, it exists perhaps in another universe.

If the patient is resuscitated, revived, this quantum information can go back into the microtubules and the patient says “I had a near death experience”‘

He adds: “If they’re not revived, and the patient dies, it’s possible that this quantum information can exist outside the body, perhaps indefinitely, as a soul.”

This account of quantum consciousness explains things like near-death experiences, astral projection, out of body experiences, and even reincarnation without needing to appeal to religious ideology.  The energy of your consciousness potentially gets recycled back into a different body at some point, and in the mean time it exists outside of the physical body on some other level of reality, and possibly in another universe.

Robert Lanza on Biocentrism:

Sources:

Learning Mind

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Biocentric_universe

http://www.dailymail.co.uk/sciencetech/article-2225190/Can-quantum-physics-explain-bizarre-experiences-patients-brought-brink-death.html#axzz2JyudSqhB

http://www.news.com.au/news/quantum-scientists-offer-proof-soul-exists/story-fnenjnc3-1226507686757

http://www.psychologytoday.com/blog/biocentrism/201112/does-the-soul-exist-evidence-says-yes

http://www.hameroff.com/penrose-hameroff/fundamentality.html

– See more at: http://www.spiritscienceandmetaphysics.com/scientists-claim-that-quantum-theory-proves-consciousness-moves-to-another-universe-at-death/#sthash.yzZunPKU.dpuf

Advertisements

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s